The short answer
Contingency fits roles where you want to pay only when someone is hired. Flat-fee retained search fits senior, confidential, or hard-to-fill roles where you want a committed search at a known cost. Recruiting as a Service fits steady hiring of several roles a quarter. Volume, seniority, and how much risk you want to carry decide which one is right.
There are four common ways to pay a recruiting firm: contingency, traditional retained search, flat-fee retained search, and Recruiting as a Service. None of them is the best model for every hire. Each one fits a different combination of seniority, hiring volume, and how much risk you want to carry, and picking the wrong one costs you either money or months.
The Four Models at a Glance
- Contingency: you pay a percentage of first-year salary, only when a candidate the firm presented is hired.
- Traditional retained: you pay a percentage of first-year compensation, often in the 25% to 33% range, in installments that start before anyone is hired.
- Flat-fee retained: you pay a fixed fee set by role level, in installments, for a committed search.
- Recruiting as a Service (RaaS): you pay a monthly subscription for a dedicated recruiting team plus a smaller fee per hire.
Contingency Recruiting
Contingency puts the risk on the recruiter. If no one is hired, you owe nothing, which makes it a sensible choice for roles with a healthy candidate market, for companies testing a new recruiting partner, and for hires where you are also sourcing on your own. The trade-off is that contingency searches are often non-exclusive, so a recruiter splits attention across many clients and moves fastest on roles most likely to close.
Colossus runs contingent search at 25% of first-year base salary, billed on the hire's start date, with a 4-month replacement guarantee and no upfront cost.
Traditional Retained Search
Retained search buys commitment. The firm is engaged exclusively, works the role to completion, and usually runs a deeper assessment before presenting anyone. It is the standard for senior and confidential searches. The drawback is cost: because the fee is a percentage of compensation, it rises with the offer, and the firm earns more when your candidate negotiates a higher package.
Flat-Fee Retained Search
Flat-fee search keeps the commitment of a retained search and removes the link between the fee and the offer. The fee is set by role level before the search starts, so you know the cost on day one and nobody has a financial reason to push the salary up.
- Individual contributor: $15,000
- Lead: $18,000
- Manager: $22,500
- Director: $35,000
- VP or SVP: $45,000
- C-suite: $55,000
Colossus bills flat-fee search in thirds, with the first third due when the search starts, and backs every flat-fee placement with a 12-month replacement guarantee.
Recruiting as a Service
RaaS is built for volume. Instead of paying a separate fee for each search, you pay a monthly subscription for a recruiting team that works every open role, plus a smaller fee when each hire starts. At Colossus that is $10,000 a month plus $4,500 per hire, with unlimited searches and a 12-month guarantee. It pays off when you are hiring several roles every quarter; for two or three hires a year, per-search pricing usually costs less.
The Fee Math at Real Salary Levels
At a 25% contingency rate, here is the base salary at which each Colossus flat fee becomes the cheaper option:
- Individual contributor ($15,000 flat): flat fee costs less above $60,000 base
- Lead ($18,000 flat): above $72,000 base
- Manager ($22,500 flat): above $90,000 base
- Director ($35,000 flat): above $140,000 base
- VP or SVP ($45,000 flat): above $180,000 base
- C-suite ($55,000 flat): above $220,000 base
Below those salaries, contingency is the cheaper fee. Above them, flat-fee search costs less and adds the longer guarantee. A Controller at $160,000 base, for example, would cost $40,000 on contingency and $35,000 as a Director-level flat-fee search.
How to Choose
- How senior is the role? Director and above usually justify a committed, retained-style search.
- Is it confidential? Replacing someone who is still in the seat calls for an exclusive, retained search.
- How many hires this year? Several roles a quarter is where RaaS starts to beat per-search fees.
- How healthy is the candidate market? Plentiful, active candidates suit contingency; scarce or passive ones need a committed search.
- How much guarantee do you need? Senior hires often show fit problems after the first quarter, which favors a 12-month window.
Common Questions
What is the difference between retained and contingency recruiting?
A contingency firm is paid only if you hire a candidate it presented, usually as a percentage of first-year salary. A retained firm is paid in installments to run a committed, usually exclusive search, with part of the fee paid before anyone is hired.
How much does a contingency recruiter charge?
Contingency fees are a percentage of the hire's first-year base salary. Colossus charges 25%, billed on the hire's start date, with a 4-month replacement guarantee.
When is a flat recruiting fee cheaper than a percentage fee?
Once base salary passes the point where the percentage fee exceeds the flat fee. At a 25% rate, a $35,000 Director-level flat fee costs less than contingency on any base salary above $140,000.
Tagged
Austin Younglove
Founder & CEO, Colossus Search Group
Austin founded Colossus Search Group in Phoenix to give growing companies one partner for attracting, hiring, keeping, and growing talent.