Hire
Manufacturing

How to Hire a COO or VP of Operations for a Manufacturing Company

By Austin Younglove, Founder & CEO Updated 4 min read

The short answer

Start by deciding which job you need: a single-site Plant Manager, a multi-site VP of Operations, or a COO who owns supply chain, quality, and engineering across the business. Then assess for P&L ownership, lean practice, multi-site leadership, and the ability to drive change, not years in the industry alone.

Manufacturing operations leadership is its own discipline. The skills are specialized, strong candidates are spread across industrial corridors rather than concentrated in one metro, and the best of them are rarely job hunting. A good search starts by being precise about which operations role you actually need.

Decide Which Job You Are Hiring For

A Plant Manager or Site Director owns a single facility. A VP of Operations typically owns production across several sites or the whole production function. A manufacturing COO usually carries enterprise accountability across supply chain, quality, engineering, and continuous improvement, and reports to the CEO or a PE sponsor.

To decide between them, answer one question: what is the CEO not doing today that needs to get done? If the answer is running the plants, you need a VP of Operations. If it is running the entire internal half of the business, you need a COO.

The Five Types of COO

  • The Executor turns the CEO's plan into daily operating reality.
  • The Change Agent is brought in to rebuild process, people, and systems.
  • The Mentor pairs with a first-time CEO to add experience and stability.
  • The Partner shares strategic ownership and runs the internal side of the business.
  • The Heir Apparent is being prepared to succeed the CEO.

What Strong Manufacturing Operators Have in Common

  • Real P&L accountability: they have owned cost centers with financial consequences.
  • Practitioner-level lean, Six Sigma, or kaizen experience, not just familiarity.
  • Multi-site leadership across different plants, cultures, and shifts.
  • ERP fluency at your scale, whether SAP, Oracle, Epicor, or another system.
  • Capital project experience: expansions, automation, and equipment upgrades.
  • Labor relations experience, especially in union environments.

Why COO Hires Fail

COO hires fail more often from a broken CEO and COO relationship than from a lack of competence. Before the search starts, the CEO needs to answer three questions honestly: what authority will the COO have, which decisions can they make alone, and is the CEO genuinely ready to hand over operational control?

Where These Candidates Come From

Strong operations leaders are running lines, managing shifts, and fixing quality problems, not browsing job boards. The most reliable sources are direct outreach to leaders at competitors and adjacent manufacturers, referrals through industry networks, and associations such as ASCM, AME, and NAM.

What the Role Pays

Colossus's 2026 salary guides put typical mid-market base salary at $260K to $445K for a COO and $180K to $320K for a VP of Operations, with an estimated median of $131K for a Plant Manager. Bonus and equity add meaningfully at PE-backed companies.

The Assessment Mistake Most Companies Make

The most common mistake is over-weighting industry experience and under-weighting leadership and change management. The best candidates combine deep manufacturing knowledge with the ability to build teams, communicate across functions, and move a culture. Assess both.

One Question Worth Asking Every Finalist

"Tell me about a time the CEO made a decision you disagreed with and you had to execute it anyway. What did you do?" The answer shows executive maturity, judgment, and how the candidate will handle the relationship that most often decides whether a COO succeeds.

Common Questions

What is the difference between a COO and a VP of Operations in manufacturing?

A VP of Operations typically owns production across one or more sites. A manufacturing COO usually carries enterprise accountability across supply chain, quality, engineering, and continuous improvement, and reports to the CEO or PE sponsor.

How much does a manufacturing COO make?

Colossus's 2026 salary guide puts typical mid-market COO base salary at $260K to $445K and VP of Operations base at $180K to $320K, before bonus and equity.

Why do COO hires fail?

Usually because the CEO and COO never agreed on authority and decision rights, not because the COO lacked skill. Settle those before the search starts.

Tagged

ManufacturingCOOVP of OperationsPlant Manager
C

Austin Younglove

Founder & CEO, Colossus Search Group

Austin founded Colossus Search Group in Phoenix to give growing companies one partner for attracting, hiring, keeping, and growing talent.